PowerCreamer Blog

Beyond the Milk and Sugar: Coffee Creamer Substitute

There are plenty of things you can add to your coffee that are not a typical coffee creamer. If you drink coffee regularly, as most of us do, and you always have it the same way, it might be time to spice things up a bit and make a change in the form of a coffee creamer substitute.

Many people add a lot of things to their coffee, most of which are not the healthiest options. We tend to add a lot of sugar and several glugs of milk or creamer. Sometimes we even put so much that we disguise the actual taste of the coffee. However, you can easily switch things up to make your coffee not only taste difference but also be healthier.

Why Substitute creamer?

The primary reason to make a switch is just to try a different flavor. When you add so much to your coffee, you are almost masking its original taste. By substituting your creamer, you can get back to enjoying other, more natural flavors.

The second reason is that using a substitute for creamer is simply healthier in a lot of ways. By putting sugar and milk or creamer in your coffee, you could be adding a whopping 500 calories to your cup of coffee. You want to avoid that as much as possible, especially if you are enjoying multiple cups a day.


There are plenty of things you can use as a coffee creamer substitute. Some rather unique ones include cacao butter, butter, egg yolks, collagen powder, and oil. Other more traditional options include honey and pumpkin. Finally, PowerCreamer is a great coffee creamer substitute.

Cacao Butter

Cacao butter will give you a hint of chocolate in your coffee and there isn’t much that tastes better than coffee and chocolate mixed together. You can let the fat melt after you’ve added the cacao butter and then just mix it up. You can even add an extra teaspoon of cocoa powder to the mixture and enjoy an even stronger chocolate taste.


Butter might seem like a weird option but it is actually quite popular. The extra fat in the butter can help your body to respond more slowly to the caffeine hit so you won’t get such a big crash once the caffeine wears off. And many who use butter in their coffee really love the taste.

Butter is a good choice of coffee creamer substitute.

Egg Yolks

Egg yolks might seem hard to get used to in your coffee but they give you a great boost of nutrients and they bulk up your brew. It will be thicker and smoother once you add the egg yolks.

Collagen Powder

Collagen powder is a pretty new addition to the coffee creamer substitute list. However, it has some really amazing properties. It you want to start your day off in a healthy way, this might be the way to go and you’ll get some anti-aging properties to go along with your morning coffee. You won’t really get a very strong taste from the collagen powder, but it does add some protein to your drink and it does some really great things for your skin.


Oil might seem like a strange option to put in your coffee, but it contains a whole lot of medium-chain triglycerides which will give you a boost of energy along with your boost of caffeine.


Honey is most known for being an additive to tea, but it also works great in coffee. It will give you a nice sweet taste without having to use refined sugar


Pumpkin is a pretty common flavor of specialized coffee houses, and it has some of its own health benefits, but you don’t have to spend that kind of money on a drink you can make at home. When you add real pumpkin to your coffee and use it as a coffee creamer substitute, you get that same full flavor that you’re used to in the fall, without having to spend money on coffeehouse prices.


What we find to be the best coffee creamer substitute is PowerCreamer. With this option, you don’t have to lose out on flavor. You can still enjoy a hint of something other than the traditional coffee flavor without adding so many unnatural and unhealthy ingredients to your cup of Joe. And there are four flavors form which you can choose so you can switch it up as well. Flavors include cinnamon, vanilla, original, and cacao.

There are so many ways to mix up the flavor in your coffee without having to use a traditional coffee creamer. Using a coffee creamer substitute from our list means that you get to try new flavors mostly guilt-free. Ditch the fat and extra sugar and enjoy some new flavor with your morning brew. 


Omega Health Products

Leave a Reply

Notify of

Follow Us

Show us some love!